Is Buying a Bigger House Worth It? The Pros and Cons of Upsizing Your Home

Expanding your living space by purchasing a bigger house is a major decision that demands careful consideration of various factors. 

While additional square footage and enhanced amenities may seem exciting, assess the potential benefits and drawbacks before taking the leap.

What's in this article?

The pros of buying a bigger house
The cons of buying a bigger house
Other financial considerations of buying a bigger house
Get expert mortgage guidance to buy a bigger house

The pros of buying a bigger house

Upgrading to a larger home can be exciting, offering numerous benefits that cater to various lifestyle needs and long-term goals. 

While the decision to purchase a bigger property involves careful consideration of financial implications and personal preferences, the potential advantages can be substantial. 

Here are some of the benefits to consider when contemplating a move to a more spacious home.

More space for a growing family

As families grow, the need for additional living space becomes a necessity. 

For example, a larger home provides essential capacity for children to have their own bedrooms, providing a sense of privacy and personal space. 

Dedicated play areas or family rooms also allow for quality time together without feeling cramped or confined. 

Families can comfortably accommodate relatives or guests without compromising their living arrangements, making it easier to host gatherings or extended visits.

Accommodation for lifestyle and hobbies

A bigger house offers the flexibility to adapt to your unique lifestyle and hobbies. 

Whether you’re an avid crafter, a fitness enthusiast or a woodworker, a larger home can accommodate a dedicated space for your passions. 

This not only allows you to pursue your interests without cluttering the main living areas but also provides a sanctuary where you can immerse yourself in your favorite activities without disturbances.

Potential for rental income

Investing in a larger property can open up opportunities for generating additional income through renting out a portion of the space

Many larger homes feature separate living quarters, such as an in-law suite, a basement apartment or a detached guesthouse. 

By renting out these spaces, you can offset a portion of your mortgage payments or create a steady stream of passive income, making homeownership more financially manageable.

Increased storage and outdoor space

Larger homes often come with ample storage solutions, including walk-in closets, attics, basements or dedicated storage rooms. 

This additional storage capacity can help declutter your living areas and provide an organized space for seasonal items, family heirlooms or belongings that you’re not ready to part with.

A bigger property typically offers more outdoor space, allowing for larger yards, gardens or outdoor living areas where you can enjoy nature and entertain guests.

Ready To Take Your Next Step?

Purchase - Refinance - HELOAN/HELOC(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

The cons of buying a bigger house

While the allure of a larger living space can be tempting, consider the potential drawbacks and challenges that come with purchasing a bigger home. 

Before diving headfirst into the journey of owning a larger home, it’s essential to carefully evaluate the following potential cons of buying a bigger house.

Higher costs

One of the most significant drawbacks of purchasing a larger home is the increased costs associated with it. 

Not only is the initial purchase price typically higher, but ongoing expenses such as:

  • Monthly mortgage payments
  • Property taxes
  • Utility bills
  • Professional maintenance, if necessary 

Heating and cooling a larger space, for example, can result in substantially higher energy costs; and maintaining a bigger property may require hiring professional services, further adding to the financial burden.

Maintenance and upkeep

A bigger house often translates to more effort and time required for maintenance and upkeep, both indoors and outdoors. 

Larger living spaces demand more frequent cleaning, while expansive yards and outdoor areas necessitate regular landscaping and maintenance tasks. 

Homeowners may find themselves spending a significant amount of time and resources keeping their larger property in top condition.

Potential for wasted space

While a larger home may seem appealing, there is a risk of ending up with unused or wasted space. 

Rooms or areas that are seldom utilized can become a burden, as they still require heating, cooling and maintenance, increasing costs without providing tangible benefits. 

Careful planning and consideration of your current and future needs is crucial to avoid this pitfall.

Location trade-offs

In some cases, to afford a larger home, buyers may have to compromise on their preferred location. 

This could mean moving further away from work, schools or amenities they have grown accustomed to. 

Longer commute times, limited access to convenient amenities and potential disruptions to established social networks are factors to consider when weighing the benefits of a bigger home against the trade-offs in location.

Other financial considerations of buying a bigger house

Make sure you carefully review your financial situation. 

Budgeting for rising costs, assessing the long-term value of investments and considering alternative options are financial factors that can greatly influence your decision-making process. 

Keep the following considerations in mind during your journey.

Budgeting for increased expenses

Before deciding to purchase a larger home, consider all the associated increased expenses beyond just the purchase price. 

Whether costs are one-time or ongoing, get a feel for how much you can comfortably afford to spend on these common costs.  

Think about costs such as:

  • Down payment
  • Property taxes
  • Agent fees
  • Closing costs 
  • Maintenance costs
  • Landscaping or housekeeping needs
  • HOA (homeowner association) fees
  • Cost of any essential repairs or renovations
  • Necessary insurance costs

Long-term investment value

While a bigger home can be a valuable investment, its long-term value is not guaranteed. 

Market trends, shifts in buyer preferences and the limited pool of potential buyers for larger homes can all impact the resale value. 

It’s crucial to carefully evaluate the local real estate market and consider the potential for appreciation or depreciation before making a significant investment in a larger property.

Alternative solutions

Before committing to the purchase of a bigger house, it’s worth exploring alternative solutions that may better suit your needs and financial situation. 

Renovating your current home to add space, converting unused areas into livable spaces or even decluttering and optimizing the use of your existing square footage can be more cost-effective options. 

Carefully weighing these alternatives against the pros and cons of a larger home can help you make an informed decision aligned with your overall goals and lifestyle requirements.

Get expert mortgage guidance to buy a bigger house

Are you currently trying to decide to buy a bigger home? 

At Compass Mortgage, our mortgage specialists are dedicated to guiding you toward an informed mortgage decision. 

Connect with Compass Mortgage today to discuss your options with one of our knowledgeable professionals.